Friday, October 19, 2007 5:39 PM

Have you ditched non-stick pans?

A few years ago I stopped cooking with non-stick pans after I found out that chemicals in the coating (called PFCs) are likely to cause cancer and thyroid problems. Now it’s up for debate whether the exposure you get just from cooking an omelet on one of these pans can actually do you harm, but it’s a well-known fact among veterinarians that inhaling fumes from a hot non-stick pan can be deadly to pet birds. I figure if the fumes can kill a parrot within minutes they can’t be good for me and my family. So, I ceased using them altogether (inconveniently, I learned this info just after I’d received three spanking new All-Clad ones off of my wedding registry—and of course I’d used them once or twice so it was too late to return).

Since then I’ve learned how to cook on uncoated cast iron and stainless steel without my food adhering to the bottom like glue. It takes a little extra oil, obviously, but I figure that ingesting more fat is better for me than inhaling or consuming chemicals. I just learned that there’s a new line of non-stick pans out there called GreenPan that claims to have the advantages of traditional non-stick pans without the harmful chemicals. I don’t plan to try them because I’m a little skeptical (often when there’s a “green” invention that seems too good to be true it turns out that the new, supposedly-safer technology is just as harmful as what it’s replacing, though there’s no evidence that that’s the case here), but also because I’ve grown so attached to my Le Creuset cast iron frying pan that I no longer even miss the non-stick. And when I’ve interviewed professional chefs in the past for magazine stories they’ve told me that uncoated cast iron is hands-down their favorite type of pan.

Have you ditched non-stick? What type of pan is your favorite?


Posted by Nest Celeste
Filed under:

Comments

re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

When registering, my husband and I wanted stainless steel b/c we had heard about the chemicals in non-stick coating.  We are really glad that we got the steel, and the extra oil and careful heating is worth it!  Also, there's something nice about the simplicity of the plain metal pans.  They look like they'll last a really long time!

Posted by Molly11    Saturday, October 20, 2007 10:59 AM


re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

We received stainless for our wedding as well.  Our glass-top stove doesn't seem to heat one of the pans evenly, though.  I think if I had it to do over again, I'd do cast iron for more pieces, keep the wok we have (which is fantastic!) and get copper-bottomed stainless pots (and a new stove).

Posted by third_place    Sunday, October 21, 2007 6:40 AM


re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

YES!  Despite any health concerns or whatever, my reason is practical.  The "stuff" comes off after it's used too much, despite what kind of utensil you use.  Now, when I bake, I use the Wilton non-stick pans, but other than that, I don't use them.

Posted by erinelizabeth02    Sunday, October 21, 2007 10:28 AM


re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

I just replaced my nonstick pots and pans with a set of stainless, not necessarily because of the cancer connection, but because I wanted to be able to use the dishwasher on them.  However, I do get skeeved out by the nonstick coating flaking off of pots and pans and do NOT want to eat that.  And the nice trade-off was that we don't have to worry about the PFCs.

Posted by MrsCasey2B    Sunday, October 21, 2007 2:29 PM


re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

We were concerned about the health effects also, so we went with stainless steel ones and we love them!  I agree that they look like they'll last for a looooong time.

I do use non-stick for occaisional baking, and have one small non-stick pan for omelets, but other than that, we use the stainless steel.

Posted by naby    Sunday, October 21, 2007 6:25 PM


re: Have you ditched non-stick pans?

I got anodized aluminum pans (Calphalon and Farberware both have this) which are naturally non-stick and do not have a teflon coating.  I love them!

Posted by Meridianwings    Monday, October 22, 2007 2:58 PM


Anonymous comments are disabled