I'll recommend Plaza Jewelers on Augusta Road (right behind McAlister's Deli).
My husband and I bought our wedding bands there. The owner was the nicest guy ever.
My hubby had horrible luck picking out a wedding band. The first ring he picked out was a beautiful titanium ring. The problem with titanium is that it can't be sized, so they ordered it in his size. The ring came and it wasn't the ring we ordered. It was ugly. The manufacturer had discontinued the other ring and sent a ring (that wasn't even close) in its place.
So then he picked out another titanium ring. When it came, there was something about it that didn't match up with the picture (you could see this weird line running between the gold and the titanium).
He thought about it for a long time. He went over there one morning and decided to go with either something gold or platinum (so he could pick one out in the store and have it sized). Well he narrowed it down to 2. It was about 2 weeks until our wedding. He couldn't wait until I found a time we could go to the store together.
Guess what, the owner allowed him to take both rings home to show me! He just let him take $1200 worth of merchandise without even taking a credit card number (probably not the smartest business practice, but it shows you what a good guy he is). When my hubby finally picked out a ring, he got a good discount and he was able to get exactly what he wanted.